I Don’t Have to Love Him

James, is today the day Charlies coming round?

Emily was at the hob, stirring something in a pan, and she didnt bother to turn around. James put his phone down on the table and stretched.

Yeah, Sophies dropping him off at ten. Shell pick him up about six.

Emily nodded, but James caught a twitch in her shoulders. She turned for a momentas if reaching for the saltand in her eyes flickered something odd. Not annoyance, exactly. More like caution. Like someone bracing themselves for something unpleasant.

James didnt make a fuss. Theyd only been married half a year, and Emily still wasnt entirely used to the fact he had a seven-year-old son from his previous marriage. That was fair enough. These things took time. He told himself shed find her own way, and that would be fine.

…Charlie burst through the door bang on ten, flying straight into Jamess arms.

Dad! Dad, guess what happened today!

Sophie stood on the threshold, holding the door, gave James a nod and smiled down at Charlie.

Behave for them, wont you? Ill be back at six.

Yep! Charlie was already dragging his dad to the lounge. Dad, come see what I built in Minecraft!

The front door shut. James could hear Emily slipping quietly past them in the hallwayquick, no stoppingand vanishing into the bedroom.

The day rolled by like usual. He and Charlie built Lego castles, watched cartoons, and James triedunsuccessfullyto teach his son chess. Charlie preferred making armies with the pieces and waging imaginary battles. James laughed, ruffled his sons hair, feeling that simple, warm fatherly happiness inside.

But there was something… nagging. Just a tiny itch.

Emily didnt appear. Well, she didcoming out to the kitchen for coffeebut she ghosted past without a word, eyes averted, as if nobody was there. Charlie tried a couple of timesAuntie Emily, look at what we built!but shed just toss over her shoulder a yeah, good job and disappear again.

James put it down to tiredness, or work, or whatever.

At six oclock Sophie picked up Charlie. The usual quick doorstep phraseshow was he?, fine, same next week?, well chat. Charlie hugged James at goodbye, and James watched them head down the stairs until the front door banged shut.

Heading back inside, the flat was quiet. Empty.

Suddenly, Emily appeared, emerging from the bedroom, stretching like shed just woken up.

Shall we have some dinner at last?

James nodded.

But something inside him twinged. Shed avoided his son all day. A seven-year-old boy whod never done anything to her.

Its fine, he told himself. Shell get used to it. Just give her time.

…Two months slipped by, and eventually James let out a quiet sigh of relief. Emily thawed. She didnt hole up in the bedroom when Charlie came anymore, or sneak past them as a silent shadow. On the contraryshed joke with Charlie, teach him how to fold paper planes. Last weekend, the three of them went out to feed ducks in the park. Charlie laughed when a greedy drake snatched a whole chunk of bread from his hand, and Emily joined in, and James watched them thinkingfinally, its working out.

Then, on Saturday, his mother-in-law arrived.

Margaret showed up unannounced. Charlie was in the middle of building a fortress out of cushions on the rug. Margaret stopped in the doorway to the living room, her gaze fastening onto the boy and lingering there. Something flashed in her eyesit wasnt dislike, more a sort of uneasy distaste, like shed found a stray dog in her daughters house.

James tensed, but Charlie ran up tugging at his sleeve.

Dad, Dad, look! I built a tower!

Sophie came for Charlie after an hour. James went back to the living room, where Margaret was drinking tea.

Is he here often? she asked, eyeing James over the rim of her teacup.

Every weekend.

Margaret turned to her daughter.

And you spend time with him?

Emily nodded, but something ticked over in her facebarely a flicker. Margaret pressed her lips tight.

James wandered into the kitchen for sugar, not that he needed any. He just wanted a breather from the heavy, silent judgment in the air. When he returned, Margaret was hunched close to Emily, whispering fiercely, lips brushing her ear, Emily frowning but not pulling away. Something inside James ached.

After Margaret left, things changed.

Not overnight, but steadily. Emily began to flinch when James mentioned Charlies next visit. First just little thingsa sigh, a roll of the eyes. Then words crept in.

Hes so noisy. Gives me a headache.

Why dont you take him out to the park? Its impossible to concentrate at home.

James, Im exhausted. I want to rest at weekends, not run a crèche.

James loved her. So he tried to adapt. Invited Charlie round lessfirst every other week, then even less than that. Made up reasons for his sonwork, neighbours renovations, anything. Charlie didnt ask questions, but during those rare visits, he looked at James a bit differently.

Still, for Emily, it wasnt enough.

After another brief visitbarely three hours, and James had taken Charlie out so as not to disturb herEmily stood in the kitchen, arms folded.

James, thats enough. I dont want to see that child in our house anymore.

James froze. The words hung in the air, sharp and heavy. That child. Not Charlie. Not your son. That child.

Emily, do you realise what youre saying?

Emily didnt flinch. Standing by the window, lips pressed in a thin line, absolute certainty on her face.

I do. Im tired, James. This is my home, my weekends, my life. And I dont want to share it with someone elses child.

Hes not someone elses. Hes my son.

Exactly. Yours. Not mine.

James stepped closer, searching for her gaze, trying to reach the woman he thought he knew.

You knew when you married me. You knew I had Charlie. That hed be part of my life, visiting, in our family.

Emily shrugged, turning to the window.

I didnt think hed be here every weekend. I thought, a couple of times, an hour or two, and thats it. Not all this.

All this is my child, Emily. A seven-year-old boy who looks forward to seeing his dad.

And I look forward to proper weekends with my husband! she spun round, tears angry in her eyes. Have you any idea what its like for me? I come home, shattered, just want a rest, and theres always the noise, the running, toys everywhere!

Hes a kid, Emily. Kids make noise, they run about, they leave toys. Thats normal.

Its normal for you! she nearly shouted. Youre his father, you have to love him. I dont! I never agreed to this!

James had spent months convincing himself itd be alright, that Emily would accept, even come to care for Charlie. Hed shrunk the visits, come up with excuses, watched the happiness fade from Charlies eyes every time a weekend was cancelled. And what for? For this?

You need to leave, he said quietly.

Emily flinched.

What?

Leave. Pack up and go.

She stepped towards him, face twisted in fury.

So youre chucking me out? Seriously? For the sake of a child?!

For my son, Emily.

You just want to run back to your ex! she shrieked, voice cracking. Thats what this is! Found an excuse to get rid of me, yeah? Pushing me out so you can go crawling back to Sophie!

James snapped. Something inside him broke, and the words hed held in spilled out.

I love you! Do you hear me? I love you! But I love my son too, and Im not giving him up. Not for you, not for anyone.

They stared, breathing hard, and the gulf between them felt unbridgeable. Emily fell silent, then turned and stalked into the bedroom. James heard her throwing things into a bag, the cupboard doors banging.

Twenty minutes later, the front door closed behind her.

The divorce took three months. Papers, signatures, splitting up what little they had. Emily took her things and vanished from his life, as if the year theyd shared had never happened.

…Sophie brought Charlie on Saturday morning. The boy dashed into the living roomJames had bought that remote-controlled car Charlie had been dreaming about for ages. A squeal of delight rang out from the lounge.

Sophie lingered in the hall for a moment. She looked at James properlynot judging, not pitying.

He was upset, you know, she said quietly, making sure Charlie couldnt hear. Last few months. Thought you didnt want him around anymore. That you didnt love him.

Jamess throat tightened. He remembered every cancelled weekend, every excuse, his sons searching gaze.

Things are going to be different now, he said. Ill put it right.

Sophie nodded and left.

James shut the door, heading into the living room. Charlie sat on the floor, totally absorbed with his new car, weaving it among chair legs. Hearing his dads footsteps, he looked up, his face shining with pure, unguarded joy. James felt his eyes sting.

He knelt beside his son.
Hed never let him down again. Not ever.

Rate article
Add a comment

;-) :| :x :twisted: :smile: :shock: :sad: :roll: :razz: :oops: :o :mrgreen: :lol: :idea: :grin: :evil: :cry: :cool: :arrow: :???: :?: :!:

I Don’t Have to Love Him
Someone Else’s Guilt